photo by jgestar Very early Fenwick FF84 |
![]() |
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
native |
fenwick FF756 with cork reel seat or non-cork reel seat? |
Lead | |
|
Lets just say you had a choice of a FF756 with a cork reel seat and a FF756 with the more common metal reel seat. Which would you choose? If you don't
mind explaining, that would be alot of help to me. Thanks.
Cork Reel Seat or Non-cork Reel Seat on a Fenwick FF756? (Result) |
|||
jgestar |
|||
|
Simple. I like the looks of the cork insert seat. There isn't much a change in the rod balance, it is purely a cosmetic preference.
Tom |
|||
harleydeen |
|||
|
I don't own or have I ever got to play with one of these models, but my vote is just from my own preferences...I like aluminum or metal reel seats.
I've built a spinning ultralight rod once and it had an all cork reel seat, I wanted to try one out, and I didn't like it. So now my youngest son has
it.
Tight Lines,
Harley Lk. Stevens, Wa. |
|||
whrlpool |
|||
|
I would be certain I liked the rod itself apart from the reel seat. Then I would get both. If I were limited to one, I'd prefer cork but wouldn't fuss
over it. I'd base the choice on the general condition of the rod. You can always change the reel seat anyway.
|
|||
NW Fish |
|||
|
The cork seat has more appeal to me, at least on the smaller/lighter rods. I'd like to find a 7 for a 4 wt with a cork seat.
|
|||
corlay |
|||
|
I believe that the cort-insert reel seats on this era of Fenwicks were up-locking?
The metal seats are down-locking. So, there's more to consider with this question, than purely material-choice alone.
"From my observations I think that most of us spend too much time worrying about our tackle and too little time
learning the intimate characteristics of the fish and streams we fish most."
- Ray Bergman
Trout, New York: Knopf 1938 |
|||
mdwwhw |
|||
|
I voted for cork, downlocking as I have a FF 755 in that configuration and enjoy it.
The best solution, of course, is one of each. My what a problem to have.
"Everything's better when wet...."
Steve Miller Band |
|||
flyboy912 |
|||
|
All of my Fenwick cork insert up locking reel seats are the same, 756, 805, several others, have the same style reel seat. That is, both ends of the reel feet
are secured to metal. Only my 605 has a semi cork reel seat, however, at the bottom, the reel foot is inserted into metal so that it is secure and the top band
then slides down on the upper reel foot which nestles on cork. My non Fenwick rods that have true cork reel seats are entirely different, having the reel
secured by two sliding bands only. I don't have the chance to use these much, so my opinion that the reel isn't as secure as the Fenwick style probably
doesn't hold much water. But remember, the Fenwick was designed for the mass market and so had to be more foolproof and secure than a more specialized
style of reel seat. JMHO Glenn
|
|||
native |
|||
|
Well, I started this poll because I already own an FF756 with metal reel seat, but had an offer for a FF756 with cork reel seat in an unrelated possible trade.
I made the trade. I traded an old canoe that needed refinished for a 756, an 858, and a medalist reel. I think we were both happy. I now own two 756's
and I have now caught fish with both. Thanks for your opinions.
|
|||
Upstreeam |
|||
|
Native, what's your preference now? I only have metal seats.
|
|||
Golfswithwolves.clarksclassicfl... |
|||
|
Many years ago I built a Fenwick blank into a 7 1/2' 5 wt. using an aluminum reel seat. After a short period of time I cut out the area of aluminum filler
and heated the cap off, then replaced the filler area with cork and reset the cap. Never regretted this change, as cork looks classier than most aluminum.
|
|||
flyboy912 |
|||
|
Upstreeam, somewhere it is stated that the cork inserts were offered only in certain years. Mine are 605-L, 705-M, 756-N, 805-M, 806-M, and 857-N, so I tend to
agree. Now the nature of these rods is considered later, and a little faster. I have many earlier and like the later. I picked up the cork insert rods thinking
they were a little nicer to have. My non cork inserts are 806-4, FF79 (6wt. 8'), 858, FL6 (786 Woodstream) and a 9010, which I need a fighting butt for,
the previous owner didn't know what it was for and threw it out. Glenn
|
|||
wb4tjh |
|||
|
I think it's basically a case of eenie, meenie, minie, moe.....I have a 4 piece 7.5 foot Voyager with the all metal reel seat and a two piece with the same
seat. I would love to have another of each , of either style, for a back up. The only real ifference I can see is the period in which they were manufactured.
Bill Anderson, Sarsota, Fl. "Bamboo is the Benchmark in flyrods". |
|||
flyboy912 |
|||
|
Yes, I agree. It's the blank, not the seat that determines its properties. As you live in Sarasota, I wonder if two identical bamboo rods, one from humid
south Florida, and one from a drier, western climate would handle differently? My furniture certainly suffers here in southern New Mexico. Yesterday we had 7%
humidity, and I look at my bamboo rods and wonder if they are being adversely affected? Glenn
|
|||
native |
|||
Upstreeam wrote:I haven't used the cork seat rod enough yet to give an accurate recommendation based on reel to rod connection, but as far as asthetics go, I like the reel seat. Its seems to come down to what you like the looks of. Function is probably the same. |
|||
paveglass |
reel seat | ||
|
It is worth the effort to keep an eye out for the cork reel seats. As pointed out above, the later years of production had uplocking reel seats which I like.
They also had the best quality blanks and mature tapers.
|
|||
Lanyard Stretcher |
|||
|
I voted cork because it looks nice on my 806. My dad's 756 and 856 have the traditional brown reel seat! Both work for me.
Mike |
|||
tonemike |
|||
|
i always prefer metal reel seats.
|
|||