My choice is very similar to your original suggestion, Scuddog. 8' - 8'6" 3/4 or 4/5 wt (with 4/5 if I could only have one). Perfect (for me) would be four piece, 4 wt., 8'6" in a tobacco brown like the 1950's glass. A glass rod like that with a slow medium action would be perfect for most of the fishing I do.
This color ... with my apologies to Joe on Bear Creek, whose photo I stole from another part of this forum...












