Yuku free message boards

Yes No Maybe lets think about it in a fresh context.

1st buy blank uncut of you can. Then you make the critical ferruling decisions. So saying why not a standard fly rod seat, either uplocking or downlocking all aluminum or even a nifty wood insert type, just don't glue in the metal butt cap. Use your choice of fly rod grips, I like cigar for this purpose. Now the important part, make up a solid glass butt extension just like some you've Im sure you've seen for fighting butts, but this time make it say 8 to 12 inches long. In any style of cork you like, with any kind of butt end piece you like. I prefer solid glass for this, and forming the cork rings right onto the extension and then turning it down in my bench mounted drill motor. If your tapered fit is good for the extension into the reel seat lets say 4 inches into a 5 inch seat and into the full section of the fly rod blank still supported under the reel seat, and it fits nice and snug into the fly rod taper, then I would suggest that while you have the works chucked up into your drill motor you cut small groves into the portion thats going into your reel seat rod butt. Just right to put a couple of O rings on that will give you that little bit extra hold when you've got the butt installed.
So now you've got a butt section with a fly rod seat, a fly rod forgrip and cut to length to size properly with your other parts.
One thing you have to keep in mind with a spinning rod is that there is a direct relationship with the reel bail line roller rotating diameter, the distance to your first big spinning guide, its ID and height held above the blank. Everything here can cause you problems if you create stresses by having the ring diameter of your first guide to big or small in relationship to your rotating diameter of the bail roller feeding and picking up your line. Likewise the hight off the rod of this first ring can greatly effect the stress on the ring, wrapping, rod and line if its too low or high. If to high it effects the location and size of your second spinning guide as well. The step down between the first and second spinning guide needs to carry that same stress flow or lack of stress down low to the blank to finally get to some smaller fly guides.
In all of the cases of factory spin fly rods I have, 5-7wts, they are designed around a smallish reel in the size of a Mitchell 308/408 or a mitchell 300/410 series, both are relatively low to the seat mounting and both have relatively small bail rotation diameters allowing smallish spinning guides. This of course is a real compromise if your going to use a fly reel with those same guides. Often the first big guide serves no real purpose its just so darn big.
On my four piece Phillipson spin fly pack rods the first section has no guide, the second section carries the fly guides, so if you had two blanks you could make two different second sections one with the two spinning guides the other with one stripping guide mounted on the upper third of the second section at a traditional distance.
On the third and fourth sections you could use any kind of guide you want.
On one Phillipson supplied 3M four piece scotchply fullflex blank spin fly Camper Special rod Orvis used one large spin guide on section two, on section three one spin guide and one snake guide, on section four three snake guides. rod is a 7ft 7wt given, a Mitchell 300 size reel fits the guide size and hieght perfectly.
On a second and earlier Orvis Spin Fly Fullflex Pack Rod based on the same blank, there are two bridged spinning guides on section two, three snake guides on section three and three snake guides on section four.
The Orvis Rods are wrapped by Orvis.

On an identical Blank, this time wrapped and labeled by Orvis as OEM for Eddie Bauer, the rod is called a Fly and Spin 7ft 7wt, the second section has one large spin guide like the first rod above, the Third section has one spinning guide like the first rod above but the second guide on this section is a large Phillipson double loop style. The four section has one Large Phillipson double loop guide and two small Phillipson double loop guide.

Finally on my 7 1/2ft Phillipson Spin Fly four piece 6wt Swamp Fox Deluxe based on a slightly longer version of this same Scotchply blank and tip over butt glass ferrules, this time PHILLIPSON followed or shall I say sense it was produced before any of the above, followed the pattern of one Spinner on the second section, one on the Third and Phillipsons double loop guides the rest of the way up. The spinner on this rod also fit the Mitchell 400 bail rotation diameter.

So you could trash the Tenessee grip, go with one butt section with a removable rubber plug, a fly seat of your choice, a fly grip of your choice, a removeable spinning rod butt section, two mid or second sections, one set up for a fly rod with one stripper high up, the other set up with a big spinning guide. Your Third section could most likely be set up with a large stripper to replace the spinning guide, Id guess a size 16 stripper would fit ok, might be about right for your second section stripper size as well, Im sure you could do the math and set it up right so your big guide on the third section would properly work. Finally all your fly guides could be Phillipson double loops. Walla a spin fly. You would end up with a removable butt and 5 fly rod sections vs the same rod above with no removable butt and four sections.

You should talk to someone like Mike McFarland, Im sure he could make you a blank with five sections the second section being duplicates for a four piece rod, you could make your own butt extension out of solid glass fishing rod stock yourself at that point. With Mike making the rod sections the ferrules would be perfect fits and you could come up with alot better selection of fly rod weights, how about a nice short 4 or 5wt that would work with a little 408 mitchell, its mega low to the blank and small bail rotation that would greatly simplify your guide sizing. The Lee Wulff four piece pack rod was designed and tested around the 308/408 sized reel but had no butt extension or Tenessee grip in its final form.

Richard