photo by Loudog99 |
![]() |
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
jbenenson |
Which stripper guide to use? |
Lead | |
|
I'm in the process of building a 7.5 ft fly rod on a Steffen Brothers blank. I want to keep a traditional feeling and thought I might try using a Mildrum
stripper. It definitely looks "pre-ceramic industrial" and it is quite heavy. So want do you think? Modern stripper, Mildrum, or agate? The rest of
the story: chrome snake guides, REC nickel silver downlocking reel seat with chestnut insert, Fenwick-style cork grip, winding check, NO hook keeper. I
haven't decided on the thread color yet.
|
|||
Mojorizing |
|||
|
10mm agate stripper. GW or Snake Brand. My choice.
|
|||
lpirrone |
|||
|
agate is nice but it adds 25-30.00 to the cost of the rod. this is fine if you are building a "spare no expense" presentation rod. as a fishing tool
i like mildrum strippers. chrome frame with the dark ring. i think they look very nice and "classic". i would use a ten. even an 8 would be large
enough for a 3wt. |
|||
jkurtz7 |
|||
|
Pac bay offers chrome strippers like the Mildrum but for less money. Jan's Netcraft has a the best deal on these that I've found. http://www.jannsnetcraft.com/boat-rod-guides/280551.aspx
J. |
|||
gaddis |
|||
|
I like the Mildrum. It's not that heavy. Besides, the weight of a stripper guide is not going to have much of an effect on the action.
|
|||
jbenenson |
|||
|
I'm going to use the one most recommended by you all: the Mildrum. Thanks for the input.
|
|||
flyfishing4goldentrout |
|||
|
Another to think about is from Ricks Rods, he still has quite a few of the original Phillipson strippers, the ring is Carbide and frame hard chromed. If Im not
using an agate guide I tend to favor the old Mildrums when available with Carbide ring, but not the newer ones I see for sale more often today. Like the Pac
Bay strippers, they have a softer ring and are and can be line cut alot easier than the harder materials such as agate or Carbide. I prefer at least a hard
stripper ring. Same holds true in the sellection of snakes. I tend to like the snake brand, they seem to last longer. Although the stainless steel snakes by
other mfg's with hard chrome plating seems to last just as long. Only the softer steel bright and blued but not chromed and un-plated SS snakes seem to
fail early. The old mildrum all brass snakes seem to last forever and matchup well with the older carbide ringed stripper. The matching mildrum twin post
wrapped in, double loop tip top holds up well too. Although the brass and mildrum guides and tip tops are mostly seen today on older bamboo restorations.
Ocassionally you can find matching agate tip tops to go along with your strippers as well, that really controls ring cutting. I think thats why ceramic's
become so popular by Fuji back in the 60s, their ability to preclude cutting that is. Just make sure your getting a hard material ring in whatever stripper you
choose, also what material your snakes are based upon and coated with. Likewise the tip tops cut too so look for hard chromed SS at least. Its a pain to rewrap
a rod before its time because the guides have been line cut early.
Richard |
|||
lpirrone |
|||
|
the mildrum strippers i have been buying all have tunston carbide rings. here is the link. http://www.reelseats.com/catalog/index.php/cPath/30_55?ecSid=b1f441e9ddcb27cfe23ae13076570fff
|
|||
flyfishing4goldentrout |
|||
|
Yep those are the really good ones you want to buy, not some of the later none carbide ones Ive seen in a few suppliers ad's. They used to have a bronze
model too, I picked up a bag of 100 each 8 and 10mm several years ago from some obsolete stuff an Ebay seller had, they are really nice when your using bronze
snakes on bamboo rods. Same held true for the old bronze double loop twin post wrap on tip tops, seems more and more of the really good stuff is being replaced
by cheap overseas knockoffs today. If your gonna buy Mildrum, then these Carbide ringed models are the best and pick of the litter today!
Richard |
|||